• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Drug Policy and Law
  • Harm Reduction
  • Activism

Drugreporter

News and Films from the Frontline of the War on Drugs

  • News
  • Café
  • Videos
  • About Us
  • EN
    • HU
    • RU

The UNGASS on Drugs: Reform Aborted

April 22, 2016 | Author: Péter Sárosi

Tweet

After a long gestation, the UN drug reform experiment suffered a miscarriage. It seems the UN is not the catalyst of change but its mirror. Reformers can learn many lessons – but can also be proud of their achievements.

Those who hoped this would be a watershed event must be feeling disappointed, after the closure of the UN General Assembly Special Session. As we reported earlier, the UNGASS adopted a weak and vague outcome document on the first day, in the opening plenary, without a debate. So the plenary debates and round-table discussions, which were supposed to shed new light on the world’s efforts to control drugs, were essentially no more than lip-service, and had no real impact on the system.

I have always been among the sceptics who didn’t believe that the UNGASS would bring much change, so this was not a real disappointment for me. I think drug policy reform has never come from the UN, and it never will. The UN is only a mirror that reflects the power structure of the world and what is happening at a national level. Its systemic inertia does not permit it to be the catalyst for change.

That said, it doesn’t mean that all advocacy efforts targeting the UN are necessarily meaningless. The UN is an important forum for power-play among world powers, and provides a platform for interaction between civil society and member states. What is more, it is a stage which NGOs can use, in order to highlight the flaws of the system in front of the watching eyes of the public. That’s why we, the Rights Reporter Foundation, attended the event and produced a movie about it.

(For the YouTube version, click here!)

I couldn’t help but feel uncomfortable when governments in the “progressive camp” criticised the outcome document they had just adopted. I mean, people would be justified in asking, “Why the hell did you adopt the document without a debate, in that case?” Is maintaining the so called “Vienna consensus on drugs” so important that it justifies lending support to a document lacking any clear guidance on issues such as harm reduction, the death penalty, or the criminalisation of drug use, not to mention the regulation of drug markets?

The Czech Minister of Health, Svatopluk Nemecek, had an answer to this question. He said his government was only supporting the outcome document because it believes that this is just start of the debate, which will continue in 2019. Well, let’s hope he’s right! The world is changing, Canada announced at the UNGASS that it will legalise cannabis, Mexico announced that it will decriminalise drug use. If more and more countries are pushing for drug policy reform, it will definitely affect swinging member states which have no clear vision.

Some people have also pointed out that the outcome document includes some progressive achievements: for example, it supports access to essential medicines (partly as a consequence of repressive drug policies, millions of people cannot access pain medication). True. But the question is, what is the impact of having supportive language in the outcome document? It provides guidance for member states – but without civil society pressure, it will not be implemented at national level. We should bear in mind that changing the UN language is only the first step – using UN documents in advocacy is the next one.

For many NGOs, the UNGASS was an unpleasant experience. The UNGASS leadership changed its rules about accessing meetings daily, civil society representatives had to stand in line for hours to get in, and many of them missed the slot for their own speeches. Some people say this was intentional, aimed at excluding civil society from discussions. I don’t know the truth of it. Having stood in a queue for two hours myself to get in, I can tell you that it was not a warm welcome, not to mention stupid security rules such as the media being banned form moving around unescorted inside the building, or from doing interviews in the corridors without special permission from the media office.

Nevertheless, there was an unprecedented level of participation from civil society, often characterised by forms of expressions of emotions which are unusual in the highly formalised environment of the UN – such as NGOs cheering or booing speakers, to the great embarrassment of some diplomats. There were tons of side events, plenty of rallies and art installations around the UNGASS, and NGO speakers made the most factual and most lively interventions at the plenary and round-table debates. The voice of the movement has been heard – and it is something we can be proud of!

Drugreporter’s posters are used in action by the protesters of the Students for Sensible Drug Policy (SSDP)

I think we should be modest though, both in our expectations and self-evaluation. We should not make the same mistake the drug warriors so often make (measuring success by the number/intensity of efforts of implementation), for example when they cite an increase in police seizures as proof that prohibition works. The sheer number of NGO participants, the intensity of their speeches, selfies with ourselves at the plenary etc. do not prove that the drug reform movement is being successful. We have a long way to go, and the real battles will not be fought in the UN, but in national parliaments, local councils, schools, on the streets and most importantly, in the hearts and minds of the people.

Posted by Peter Sarosi
Videographer: Istvan Gabor Takacs, reporter: Peter Sarosi

Filed Under: Articles, Video Database Topics: Criminalisation, Drug Policy and Law, Harm Reduction, Marijuana Policies, Regulation and Control, UN Commission on Narcotic Drugs, UN Drug policy

Access to this article is free - but to produce articles and videos is not. Drugreporter is a non-profit website that needs your support to provide you with high quality contents.

Become a supporter and make a donation of 5 $ today!

Related articles:

LIFE UNDER OCCUPATION – Part II. Under the power of the Dementors

March 27, 2023 - Igor Kuzmenko

LIFE UNDER OCCUPATION – Part I. The day that changed our lives

March 20, 2023 - Igor Kuzmenko

A World Tired of Drug Prohibition: Impressions at the UN Commission on Narcotic Drugs

March 16, 2023 - Péter Sárosi

Related videos:

Support Igor Kuzmenko – a Ukrainian Video Reporter Documenting Harm Reduction during the War!

March 20, 2023 - István Gábor Takács

Fixpunkt Berlin: Supporting People Who Use Drugs in Berlin 

March 8, 2023 - Péter Sárosi

HR23 Film Festival in Melbourne – Call for Submissions!

March 3, 2023 - István Gábor Takács

You can browse our topics here:

Activism COVID-19 Criminalisation Dose of Science Drug Consumption Rooms Drug Policy and Law European Drug Policy Harm Reduction Hepatitis HIV/AIDS Marijuana Policies Medical Marijuana Needle and syringe programs New Psychoactive Substances Opiate Substitution Overdose Prevention Psychedelic Medicines Regulation and Control Russian Drug Policy Sex Work United Nations Drug Policy US Drug Policy

Primary Sidebar

BECOME A SUPPORTER OF DRUGREPORTER! INVEST THE PRICE OF A COFFEE MONTHLY AND MAKE SURE DRUGREPORTER KEEPS RUNNING!

Subscribe to the Newsletter!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Drugreporter Video Database

Hundreds of videos on drug policy, harm reduction and human rights for streaming and download, also on a world map!

DRUGREPORTER NEWS

Monthly drug policy news from around the world

Drugreporter café

In our new online video show, we regularly discuss new developments in the world of drug policy with professionals, activists and decision makers. You can also listen to the Drugreporter Café in Podcast format on Spotify or Apple Podcasts!

COVID-19 Harm Reduction Update

On this info page Drugreporter provides regular updates about resources and news on how harm reduction service providers respond to the COVID-19 Epidemic.

Drugreporter Video Advocacy Network

Browse videos produced by members of our Drugreporter Video Advocacy Network, from all around the world!

DRUG USERS NEWS

Russian language videos on drug policy, harm reduction and human rights.

Our award winning animated documentary movie is based on the original audio recording of Kostya Proletarsky, a drug user and HIV activist who died as a result of mistreatment and torture at a Russian prison. Festival appearances, news and resources are available here!

Footer

Rights Reporter Foundation
Hungary, 1032 Budapest
San Marco Street 70.
Email: rightsreporter@rightsreporter.net

Search

Our other websites:

The Rights Reporter Foundation

The Autocracy Analyst

Room for Change Campaign

Room in the 8th District Campaign

A Day in the Life movie website

Drugreporter