• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Drug Policy and Law
  • Harm Reduction
  • Activism

Drugreporter

News and Films from the Frontline of the War on Drugs

  • News
  • Café
  • Videos
  • About Us
  • EN
    • HU
    • RU

HUNGARIAN CONSTITUTIONAL COURT SAYS: „THERE IS NO RIGHT TO BE HIGH”

December 17, 2004 | Author: Péter Sárosi

Tweet

BUDAPEST 13 December 2004 – The Constitutional Court of Hungary in a 7 to 2 vote rejected the proposals claiming that drug laws that punish possession of drugs for personal use are unconstitutional. The Court accepted another proposals’ argumentation against certain forms of diversion treatment. According to the resolution, nobody has a right to be high, therefore criminal prosecution against drug users is not unconstitutional.

BUDAPEST 13 December 2004 – The Constitutional Court of Hungary in a 7 to 2 vote rejected the proposals claiming that drug laws that punish possession of drugs for personal use are unconstitutional. The Court accepted another proposals’ argumentation against certain forms of diversion treatment. According to the resolution, nobody has a right to be high, therefore criminal prosecution against drug users is not unconstitutional.

The 116 pages document argues that illicit drugs are far more dangerous than licit ones. According to the judges, „the risk of alcohol addiction is much lower than the risk of addiction to illicit drugs, because the time and dose necessary for the development of addiction is very different and the acute harms of use are much lower.” The resolution claims that drug use leads to the „loss of personal freedom”, therefore even the abridgment of personal freedom is allowed in the fight against drugs. In addition, they say, there is only one effective way to prevent the use of illicit substances: criminal prosecution.

 

The Hungarian Constitutional Court directly modified the Hungarian Penal Code: by abolishing provisions concerning certain forms of diversion-treatment they broadened the personal scope of application of the law.

 The modification was based on the proposal of Csaba Hende (independent MP, Political Secretary of State at the Ministry of Justice 1998-2002), who requested the Court to abolish certain articles of the drug legislation which came into effect in March, 2003. The new legislation allowed persons who possessed and shared small amounts of illicit drugs to chose diversion into a 6 months treatment program instead of criminal prosecution. The resolution did not completely abolish the regulations concerning diversion into therapy, but limited the scope of people who can be diverted. After Monday people who share illicit drugs for collective use cannot chose alternative therapy because the Court stated that the term „collective use” is an ambiguous and uncertain expression.

 

„There are more problems with this decision,” says Balazs Denes, Executive Director of the Hungarian Civil Liberties Union, a human rights watchdog NGO in Hungary, promoting harm reduction and critics of prohibition. ”The resolution abolished paragraphs which tried to approach a reality-based legal differentiation between drug traffickers and drug users. The Court used its power to change the criminal code from one day to another. Even the Parliament, which usually practices the legislative function, gives time for society to prepare for the changes, but the Court now changed the rules without setting such a timeframe. To top that, some parts of the reasoning used in the decision reminds us of the old-fashioned American propaganda movies from the thirties. Only one Judges’ dissent opinion contains known, quoted and researchable information on the drug phenomena, the rest based their arguments on false beliefs and stereotypes, without having consulted any experts in the matter.” 

Several weeks before the decision was made, HCLU requested the Court to release one of the original submissions, to examine its arguments and promote public discussion on it. The Court did not release the information, thus HCLU initiated a lawsuit based on the Freedom of Information Act. The first hearing of the case is going to take place on the 20th of December.

 

The decision of the Constitutional Court orders other changes as well concerning the law on drugs  which are to be implemented until 31st of May, 2005.

 

 

For immediate release!

Contact: Peter Sarosi, HCLU

sarosip@tasz.hu

+36-1-209-00-46

Filed Under: Articles Topics: Drug Policy and Law

Access to this article is free - but to produce articles and videos is not. Drugreporter is a non-profit website that needs your support to provide you with high quality contents.

Become a supporter and make a donation of 5 $ today!

Kapcsolódó cikkek:

The Italian Anti-Rave Law Violates Human Rights – Interview with Susanna Ronconi

February 1, 2023 - Péter Sárosi

Decriminalisation in Portugal: Through the Lens of People who Use Drugs

December 5, 2022 - István Gábor Takács

Drugreporter News | 2022 November

November 24, 2022 - István Gábor Takács

Kapcsolódó videók:

Decriminalisation in Portugal: Through the Lens of People who Use Drugs

December 5, 2022 - István Gábor Takács

Drugreporter News | 2022 November

November 24, 2022 - István Gábor Takács

Harm Reduction in Athens – With the Eye of an Outsider

November 23, 2022 - Péter Sárosi

You can browse our topics here:

Activism COVID-19 Criminalisation Dose of Science Drug Consumption Rooms Drug Policy and Law European Drug Policy Harm Reduction Hepatitis HIV/AIDS Marijuana Policies Medical Marijuana Needle and syringe programs New Psychoactive Substances Opiate Substitution Overdose Prevention Psychedelic Medicines Regulation and Control Russian Drug Policy Sex Work United Nations Drug Policy US Drug Policy

Primary Sidebar

BECOME A SUPPORTER OF DRUGREPORTER! INVEST THE PRICE OF A COFFEE MONTHLY AND MAKE SURE DRUGREPORTER KEEPS RUNNING!
Subscribe to the Newsletter!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Drugreporter Video Database

Hundreds of videos on drug policy, harm reduction and human rights for streaming and download, also on a world map!

DRUGREPORTER NEWS

Monthly drug policy news from around the world

Drugreporter café

In our new online video show, we regularly discuss new developments in the world of drug policy with professionals, activists and decision makers. You can also listen to the Drugreporter Café in Podcast format on Spotify or Apple Podcasts!

COVID-19 Harm Reduction Update

On this info page Drugreporter provides regular updates about resources and news on how harm reduction service providers respond to the COVID-19 Epidemic.

Drugreporter Video Advocacy Network

Browse videos produced by members of our Drugreporter Video Advocacy Network, from all around the world!

DRUG USERS NEWS

Russian language videos on drug policy, harm reduction and human rights.

Our award winning animated documentary movie is based on the original audio recording of Kostya Proletarsky, a drug user and HIV activist who died as a result of mistreatment and torture at a Russian prison. Festival appearances, news and resources are available here!

Footer

Rights Reporter Foundation
Hungary, 1032 Budapest
San Marco Street 70.
Email: rightsreporter@rightsreporter.net

Search

Our other websites:

The Rights Reporter Foundation

The Autocracy Analyst

Room for Change Campaign

Room in the 8th District Campaign

A Day in the Life movie website

Drugreporter