• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Drug Policy and Law
  • Harm Reduction
  • Activism

Drugreporter

News and Films from the Frontline of the War on Drugs

  • Videos
  • About Us
  • EN
    • HU
    • RU

Legalisation? Yes, But Not at Any Cost!

November 4, 2015 | Author: Péter Sárosi

Tweet

Ohio voters did not reject the legal regulation of cannabis – they only rejected one particular form of legalisation. We think they were wise to do so.

Issue 3, the cannabis legalisation initiative in Ohio, failed on Tuesday. This may appear surprising in the middle of a wave of support for marijuana legalisation, but it does not mean that the people of Ohio opted for prohibition. According to polls, a majority supported the legal regulation of cannabis. They only rejected the concept of a constitutionally-mandated oligopoly to control the legal cannabis market. Issue 3 would have introduced a system whereby only a few large companies were permitted to grow and distribute marijuana. The initiative divided drug policy reformers in North America. The Drug Policy Alliance and the Marijuana Policy Project abstained from endorsing the measure, but NORML, the oldest marijuana reform organisation, offered a grudging endorsement, with the reservation that an oligopoly was a bad idea.

As Ethan Nadelmann, head of the Drug Policy Alliance, wrote in his CNN opinion piece, “There’s something in a constitutionally-mandated oligopoly for an agricultural product, that just seems un-American”. Well, as a European, I think there’s also something very un-European about it. It simply seems unfair to restrict marijuana production to a handful of big corporations, when that restriction can only be modified by amending the constitution. Allocation of licences should be done by fair and open competition.

The supporters of Issue 3 also had valid arguments on their side. Marc Emery, the self-proclaimed Canadian ‘Prince of pot’, wrote, on his Facebook page, “We fight to stop arrest and punishment and prison. Any measure that moves us from complete prohibition to less prohibition / legalisation, thats what an activist does. A true activist cannot stop that consistent and worthy goal, just because someone they don’t approve of is unworthy or undeserving in making money.”

I don’t agree with him. That’s not because I, as an activist, don’t realise that in a capitalist society, for-profit corporations, (rather than idealists and non-profit collectives), will earn money from selling marijuana in a legal market. But what I like in the concept of legal regulation (I don’t really like the term legalisation) is that it differs from prohibition in its flexibility: Prohibition offers a simplistic and brutal solution to a complex problem – which is why it doesn’t work. Legal regulation is quite the opposite. It can take many forms, it can be adjusted to market needs, public health considerations and constitutional principles. You can only prohibit the distribution of a substance in one way – but you can regulate it in a great variety of ways. I don’t support any form of legal regulation that favours the interests and profits of a few corporations over those of the general public.

In the legalisation-at-any-costs approach, I sense the same simplistic narrowness that I dislike among ardent prohibitionists. I think the voters in Ohio were wise enough to reject the black-and-white fallacy, and to realise that they have multiple options available for regulating a substance. While we fight to end the global war on drugs, we should not forget the very principles that led us to question prohibition in the first place.

Peter Sarosi

Filed Under: Articles Topics: Drug Policy and Law, Marijuana Policies, Regulation and Control, US Drug Policy

Access to this article is free - but to produce articles and videos is not. Drugreporter is a non-profit website that needs your support to provide you with high quality contents.

Become a supporter and make a donation of 5 $ today!

Related articles

Civil Society Demands Balanced EU Funding for Drug Policies

July 28, 2022 - Péter Sárosi

Alternatives to Criminal Sanctions for Drug Offenders in Hungary: A Short Overview

July 11, 2022 - Péter Sárosi

Drugs Don’t Kill: Bad Drug Policies Do

July 4, 2022 - Péter Sárosi

Primary Sidebar

BECOME A SUPPORTER OF DRUGREPORTER! INVEST THE PRICE OF A COFFEE MONTHLY AND MAKE SURE DRUGREPORTER KEEPS RUNNING!
Subscribe to the Newsletter!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

In our new online video show, we regularly discuss new developments in the world of drug policy with professionals, activists and decision makers. You can also listen to the Drugreporter Café in Podcast format on Spotify or Apple Podcasts!

COVID-19 Harm Reduction Update

On this info page Drugreporter provides regular updates about resources and news on how harm reduction service providers respond to the COVID-19 Epidemic.

Browse our video database!

Hundreds of videos on drug policy, harm reduction and human rights for streaming and download, also on a world map!

Drugreporter Video Advocacy Network

Browse videos produced by members of our Drugreporter Video Advocacy Network, from all around the world!

An animated documentary movie based on the original audio recording of Kostya Proletarsky, a drug user and HIV activist who died as a result of mistreatment and torture at a Russian prison. Animation and design by Lili Rontó. Directed and Edited by István Gábor Takács. Narrated by Anya Sarang. Festival appearances, news and resources are available here!

Russian language videos on drug policy, harm reduction and human rights.

Browse our topics here!

Activism COVID-19 Criminalisation Dose of Science Drug Consumption Rooms Drug Policy and Law European Drug Policy Harm Reduction Hepatitis HIV/AIDS Marijuana Policies Medical Marijuana Needle and syringe programs New Psychoactive Substances Opiate Substitution Overdose Prevention Psychedelic Medicines Regulation and Control Russian Drug Policy Sex Work United Nations Drug Policy US Drug Policy

Footer

Rights Reporter Foundation
Hungary, 1032 Budapest
San Marco Street 70.
Email: rightsreporter@rightsreporter.net

Search

Our other websites:

The Rights Reporter Foundation

The Autocracy Analyst

Room for Change Campaign

Room in the 8th District Campaign

A Day in the Life movie website

Drugreporter